My Honest, In-Depth Review of Faber-Castell Polychromos Colored Pencils: The Ultimate Guide

For years, I dismissed colored pencils as mere playthings, relegated to coloring books and childhood sketches. I know, I know—it's a terrible admission for an artist, but hear me out. Then I discovered Faber-Castell Polychromos, and my entire perspective on what constitutes 'serious' art materials completely changed. Oh, how wrong I was! My journey with art has been a continuous unraveling of preconceived notions, and this brand was one of the most delightful revelations. These aren't your average pencil crayon; they're a revelation, a silent workhorse that has carved out a permanent spot in my studio, and frankly, in the hands of countless artists worldwide. If you've landed here, chances are you're seeking the definitive, no-holds-barred truth about these acclaimed pencils. You're wondering if they truly live up to the hype, if they're worth the investment, or how their oil-based magic truly performs. Consider this less a dry technical report and more a heartfelt sharing of a tool that has become indispensable in my artistic life. Prepare to get your hands dirty as we unpack every aspect of these remarkable pencils, exploring their nuances, and hopefully, giving you a crystal-clear picture of whether Polychromos are the next essential addition to your art kit.

A Legacy in Every Stroke: Why Faber-Castell Endures

Before we even get to the feel of the pencil, it’s worth noting the heritage. Faber-Castell isn't some fly-by-night operation that popped up last week; they've been crafting art and writing instruments for centuries, since 1761 to be precise! When you pick up a Polychromos, you’re not just holding a pencil; you're holding a piece of that rich history, a tradition of quality that has not only adapted but consistently innovated and endured through generations of artists. Their commitment to excellence stems from a meticulous approach to sourcing the finest pigments and perfecting their manufacturing processes. It’s this deep-rooted dedication to consistent quality control, coupled with a keen ear for artists' evolving needs, that has cemented their reputation. You can feel that foundation in every pencil.

credit, licence

This particular advertisement, likely from the early 20th century, isn't just a historical curiosity; it’s a testament to the brand's long-standing dedication to artists, showcasing their range and the very genesis of the Polychromos line—a name that literally means "many colors."

First Impressions: A Tactile Experience

From the moment you hold a Polychromos, there's a certain weight and balance that just feels 'right.' The barrel is round, fitting comfortably in the hand, and the cedar wood casing is smooth, sharpening beautifully without splintering. (Oh, how I loathe cheap pencils that shred themselves in the sharpener – a constant frustration I happily avoid with these!) The colors themselves, even before you lay them down, are vibrant, hinting at the rich pigments within. It's a small detail, but the overall presentation whispers quality, not shouts it.

The Core of the Matter: Pigment, Performance, and Purity

This is where the magic truly happens, and frankly, where Polychromos sets itself apart. These are oil-based colored pencils, and that's a significant distinction from the more common wax-based varieties. This oil base gives them a unique character that I've come to adore, allowing for a level of control and vibrancy that can feel transformative.

Pigment Quality and Vibrancy: Colors That Sing

Let's talk about the colors. Oh, the colors! They are incredibly rich, intense, and vibrant. There’s a depth to them that truly allows you to explore the full spectrum of your palette and understand how artists use color effectively to evoke emotion and create stunning visual narratives. When you press down, you get a beautiful, consistent laydown of pigment, a smooth deposit that almost feels like silk on paper. It’s truly a joy.

But it's not just about immediate impact; it's about endurance. The lightfastness (how resistant a pigment is to fading over time when exposed to light) of Polychromos is absolutely top-tier. Most colors are rated with three stars (***), which correlates to over 100 years of excellent lightfastness on the Blue Wool Scale when stored under museum conditions. This is a non-negotiable for any artist serious about creating works that will last. I mean, what’s the point of pouring your soul onto paper if it's going to vanish into a faded whisper a few years down the line? For me, knowing my work will endure is a huge part of its value, ensuring my creative journey culminates in lasting pieces.

The Blending Ballet: Layering Like a Dream

This is perhaps my absolute favorite characteristic of Polychromos. Because they are oil-based, they allow for incredible layering and blending. Think of it like glazing with oil paints, where each translucent layer subtly alters and deepens the color beneath. You can build up color gradually, creating smooth transitions and rich, complex hues without the dreaded wax bloom you sometimes get with wax-based pencils – that hazy, milky film that appears after heavy application because the wax binder migrates to the surface, especially with temperature changes or heavy pressure. It genuinely feels like painting with pencils! I can lay down ten, even twenty layers sometimes, slowly deepening a shadow or shifting a hue, and the paper just accepts it, never feeling oversaturated or waxy. This capacity for subtle gradation and building profound depth is what makes them so versatile, allowing me to add intricate texture and visual interest to my drawings.

Durability and Practicality: Built to Last

The leads are surprisingly robust, a testament to their careful formulation. While no pencil is entirely immune to breakage if dropped (trust me, my studio floor has endured countless accidental 'stress tests' on behalf of my readers), the Polychromos leads resist crumbling and snapping during use and sharpening much better than many softer, waxier pencils. This is due to their firmer, oil-based core which holds a fine point for an impressive amount of time, allowing for extended periods of detailed work without constant re-sharpening. This means less wasted pencil, less time spent fussing with a sharpener, and far less frustration in the middle of a delicate drawing. For those just starting out, this durability is a godsend, preventing the demoralizing experience of a constantly breaking tip, which can be a common beginner frustration.

Polychromos vs. The Contenders: A Quick Look

In the vibrant arena of artist-grade colored pencils, Polychromos are giants, but they stand alongside other esteemed brands, each offering a unique experience. To help you navigate these choices, here’s a brief comparison with a couple of other popular choices, just to give you some context on different art supplies and how they relate to various paint types.

credit, licence

Feature	Faber-Castell Polychromos	Prismacolor Premier	Caran d'Ache Luminance
Base	Oil-based	Wax-based	Oil/wax blend
Feel	Firmer, allows for fine detail and many layers	Creamy, buttery, lays down color quickly	Buttery smooth, slightly softer than Polychromos
Blending/Layering	Exceptional layering, seamless blending, no wax bloom	Good blending, prone to wax bloom with heavy layers, can feel 'waxy'	Excellent blending, highest archival lightfastness
Lead Durability	Very robust, resists breakage during sharpening and use	Softer lead, can break more easily, faster tip dulling	Good durability, retains point well for its softness
Lightfastness	Top-tier (mostly *** Blue Wool Scale), excellent for archival work	Varies by color (some good, many fair to poor for archival)	Industry-leading (mostly ASTM D-6901 compliant), truly archival
Archival Quality	Excellent, suitable for professional and exhibition pieces	Variable, less reliable for long-term archival work	Superior, designed for ultimate longevity and museum display
Price Point	Higher price point, a significant investment	Mid-range, more accessible than Polychromos or Luminance	Very high price point, premium investment
Best For	Detailed work, smooth gradients, archival pieces, artists preferring control	Bold, expressive work, quick coverage, opaque layering, students/hobbyists	Professional artists, collectors, fine art where ultimate lightfastness is paramount

For an even deeper dive into a popular wax-based alternative, you might find my in-depth review of Prismacolor Premier colored pencils particularly useful.

Are They For You? Unpacking the Ideal User

This is the million-dollar question, isn't it? Based on my extensive experience, Polychromos are not just good pencils; they're partners in the creative process for specific types of artists. They excel when you approach your art with a certain intention.

Polychromos are ideal for:

1. The Serious Artist & Archivist: If you're creating pieces for sale, exhibition, or simply want your work to endure for generations, the exceptional lightfastness and archival quality are, in my opinion, non-negotiable. Think botanical artists, hyperrealist portrait artists, or anyone documenting subjects where color accuracy and longevity are paramount.
2. For Detail Lovers & Illustrators: The fine, firm point they hold allows for incredibly intricate work. If you revel in rendering tiny textures, delicate details, or crisp lines in illustrations, architectural renderings, or fine art drawings, these pencils will sing in your hands. They demand precision, and they deliver it beautifully.
3. For Layering Enthusiasts: If you, like me, love building up colors slowly, creating depth and luminosity through multiple translucent layers, Polychromos are designed for you. The way the pigments intermingle, almost like a glaze, is a pure joy to behold, allowing for rich, complex color mixes directly on the paper.
4. For Those Who Appreciate Durability & Efficiency: Less breakage means less frustration, which is a massive win in my book. Who has time for constantly sharpening a crumbling lead when inspiration strikes? Their robustness keeps you in the creative flow.

Who Might Find Them Challenging Initially?

However, if you're a beginner looking for something super soft and buttery right out of the gate, or if you primarily do loose, gestural work that demands immediate, heavy color payoff with minimal pressure, you might find their firmer feel a slight adjustment initially. They reward patience and build-up, rather than instant gratification. But trust me, once you get the feel for them, they are incredibly rewarding and surprisingly versatile. Their learning curve is a small price to pay for the control and longevity they offer.

credit, licence

Practical Application: My Go-To Techniques and a Few Quirks

In my studio, I primarily use Polychromos for my abstract drawings and preparatory sketches for paintings. The ability to create subtle shifts in tone and color makes them perfect for exploring complex ideas before committing to a larger canvas. I often start with very light layers, gradually building density, almost like a meditation. This process really allows me to embrace my creative flow and allows for a lot of experimentation without fear of ruining a piece too early.

Here are a few techniques I rely on with Polychromos:

• Feather-Light Layers: Start with the lightest possible pressure, applying broad, even strokes. This builds a foundation of color without saturating the paper too quickly, allowing for maximum layering potential. It’s a patient process, but the results are absolutely worth it.
• Circular Blending: For seamless transitions and smooth areas of color, I often use small, overlapping circular motions. This helps to eliminate visible pencil strokes and creates a more painterly finish. It's particularly effective for skin tones or smooth gradients in landscapes.
• Burnishing with a Colorless Blender (or white Polychromos): This is my secret weapon. Applying a colorless blender (or even a white Polychromos) with firm pressure over existing layers compresses the pigment, fills the paper tooth, and creates a super smooth, almost glossy finish. It intensifies the colors beautifully, making them truly pop by creating a more unified and reflective surface. It's like magic watching the colors suddenly come alive!
• Cross-Hatching for Texture and Depth: For areas where I want more visual texture or a faster build-up of value, cross-hatching works wonderfully. The firm point of the Polychromos allows for clean lines even when layering many strokes, maintaining crispness even in dense areas. To dive deeper into various drawing approaches, exploring topics like mark making can be immensely helpful.
• Working with Solvents: A fantastic advantage of their oil-based nature is their compatibility with solvents. A small brush dipped in odorless mineral spirits (like Gamsol) can be used to dissolve and spread the pigment, creating beautiful, paint-like washes and even smoother blends. Just be sure to use suitable paper and work in a well-ventilated area!

Investing in Your Craft: Price and Care

The Price Tag: An Investment, Not Just a Purchase

Let's talk about the elephant in the room: the price. Yes, Faber-Castell Polychromos are more expensive than student-grade pencils, and even some other artist-grade brands. But here’s how I genuinely see it: you’re not just buying pencils; you’re investing in your art. You’re investing in tools that won't fade, that will perform consistently, and that will make the artistic process more enjoyable and less frustrating.

To give you a clearer picture, while a small set of 12 might seem a bit steep initially, the cost per pencil significantly decreases with larger sets. For example, a 12-set might cost around €3-€4 per pencil, whereas a 60-set or 120-set can bring the individual cost down to €2-€2.50 per pencil. This makes the larger sets a more economical long-term investment for serious artists or those committed to the medium. They last a long time, the quality is undeniable, and the results speak for themselves. If you're looking to explore my art and see the depth of color and texture I achieve, you'll understand why I value tools that deliver such reliable, high-performance results.

Care and Maintenance: Protecting Your Investment

These aren't disposable tools, so treating them with a little care goes a long way. I recommend storing your Polychromos in their original tins or a dedicated pencil case to prevent them from rolling off your desk (been there, done that!) and protect the leads from accidental drops. While they are robust, unnecessary trauma can still lead to breakage. Also, invest in a good quality sharpener – one designed for artist-grade pencils. I personally favor manual crank sharpeners like the Kum Automatic Long Point or a quality blade sharpener like the Caran d'Ache brand, as they provide a consistent, sharp point without splintering the beautiful cedar casing or damaging the lead, thus wasting precious pigment. Avoid cheap, plastic sharpeners at all costs; they're a false economy!

credit, licence

Pros and Cons: A Quick Summary

To wrap up my thoughts before we get to your questions, here’s a straightforward breakdown of what I love and what might be a slight hurdle.

Pros

• Exceptional Pigment Quality: Vibrant, rich colors with industry-leading lightfastness (*** Blue Wool Scale), ensuring your artwork endures for generations.
• Superior Blending & Layering: The oil-based formula allows for seamless transitions and deep color saturation without the frustration of wax bloom, feeling almost like painting.
• Durable, Point-Retaining Leads: Incredibly robust, resisting breakage and crumbling during both use and sharpening, which means less waste and more creative flow. They hold a fine point exceptionally well.
• Comfortable Handling: Ergonomic design and smooth cedar casing contribute to a pleasant and fatigue-free drawing experience, even during long sessions.
• Archival Quality: A crucial feature for professional artists, ensuring your work remains vibrant and true for decades.
• Versatile with Solvents: Can be used effectively with odorless mineral spirits for paint-like effects and enhanced blending.

Cons

• Higher Initial Investment: Can be a significant initial cost compared to student-grade options, though the cost per pencil is reduced in larger sets, making it a long-term investment in quality.
• Firmer Feel & Learning Curve: May require a bit more pressure and patience to achieve heavy application compared to softer, wax-based pencils, which might take some getting used to. This is less a 'con' and more a characteristic that rewards adaptation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1: Are Faber-Castell Polychromos good for beginners?

A: While they are artist-grade and a bit of an investment, I actually think they are excellent for serious beginners. Their blending capabilities teach you a lot about color theory and layering, and their durability means less frustration from constantly breaking leads. Just be aware they have a firmer feel than some very soft pencils, so a light touch and building layers are key.

Q2: What's the main difference between oil-based and wax-based colored pencils?

A: Oil-based pencils (like Polychromos) tend to be firmer, hold a sharper point longer, and allow for many layers without wax bloom. They blend beautifully, often responding well to solvents. Wax-based pencils are often softer, lay down color more quickly with less pressure, but can be prone to wax bloom and don't always take as many layers before the paper's 'tooth' is filled, leading to a waxy buildup.

Q3: Are Polychromos lightfast?

A: Yes, absolutely! One of their strongest features is their high lightfastness ratings. Most colors are rated with three stars (***), meaning excellent lightfastness according to the Blue Wool Scale, which is crucial for archival artwork that you want to last a lifetime and beyond. This is why they're a top choice for professional artists.

Q4: Can you mix Polychromos with other brands of colored pencils?

A: Absolutely! Many artists, including myself, love to mix and match. Polychromos often layer beautifully over softer wax-based pencils, adding detail or burnishing, and can also be used as an initial layer for wax-based pencils. Experimentation is key to finding your unique approach and discovering new textural possibilities!

Q5: What surfaces work best with Polychromos?

A: They are incredibly versatile. I've used them successfully on various papers from smooth bristol to textured watercolor paper. The smoother the paper, the more layers and intricate detail you can achieve, while textured paper provides a lovely tooth for rich pigment application and interesting visual effects. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference and the desired outcome, but generally, any good quality drawing paper with a bit of tooth will serve them well.

Q6: What's the difference between Polychromos and Faber-Castell Albrecht Dürer watercolor pencils?

A: This is a common question! Both are artist-grade pencils from Faber-Castell, but they serve different purposes. Polychromos are permanent, oil-based colored pencils designed for dry application and blend beautifully through layering or with solvents. Albrecht Dürer pencils, on the other hand, are water-soluble watercolor pencils. They can be used dry like regular colored pencils, but their magic lies in their ability to be activated with water to create watercolor effects, washes, and smooth transitions, making them a fantastic hybrid medium. The choice depends on whether you primarily want dry, layered color or watercolor-like effects.

Final Strokes: My Enduring Affection for Polychromos

If you haven't guessed by now, I'm not just a fan; I'm an ardent admirer of Faber-Castell Polychromos. They've earned their place as a staple in my studio, not just for their technical prowess but for the sheer joy and possibilities they bring to the creative process. They challenge you to slow down, to observe, to build color with intention. They’ve opened up a whole new realm of possibilities in my drawing, allowing me to approach my creative journey with a different kind of focus and a newfound appreciation for the humble colored pencil. This commitment to quality and the ability to create such lasting, vibrant work is exactly what I strive for in my own abstract art prints and originals.

So, if you're on the fence, I urge you to try them. Start with a small set or a few individual pencils in colors you use often. You might just find, like I did, that these pencils aren't just tools; they're partners in your artistic adventure, ready to transform your approach and make your art sing. Your artistic journey might just be about to get a lot more colorful.