Derwent vs. Faber-Castell: The Definitive Artist's Guide to Colored Pencils

The studio. Your sanctuary. Your canvas awaits. But the first hurdle? Those tempting, often intimidating sets of artist-grade colored pencils. Derwent vs. Faber-Castell – a debate as vibrant as the colors themselves, and one that resonates deeply with anyone serious about their craft. I know what you’re thinking: another comparison? But this isn't just about brand loyalty; it’s about understanding the very soul of your tools. It’s about figuring out which pigment-packed warrior belongs in your arsenal, genuinely shaping your artistic process. We’re going to dissect their core compositions, their color payoff, their layering prowess, and ultimately, how they feel in your hand. Is this an artistic breakthrough waiting to happen, or are you about to make a Faustian bargain with your budget? This is your definitive guide to making an informed decision, an investment not just in supplies, but in your creative potential. We'll explore everything from their historical roots to specific techniques, ensuring you walk away with clarity and confidence.

credit, licence

The Foundational Differences: Beyond Just Wax and Oil

Why dedicate so much thought to just two brands? Because Derwent and Faber-Castell represent two distinct philosophies in the artist-grade colored pencil universe. First, let's clarify: Artist-grade isn't just a fancy label; it signifies pencils with a significantly higher concentration of pure pigment, superior lightfastness (their resistance to fading over time due to UV light and atmospheric exposure), and more durable binders. This means richer, more vibrant colors, better blending capabilities, and artwork that stands the test of time. It's the crucial difference between a fleeting sketch and a generational masterpiece, and a key consideration for anyone creating work for display or sale. Forget the flimsy student-grade pencils that crumble and fade – this is about tools that genuinely elevate your craft.

Faber-Castell Polychromos, with their renowned oil-based cores, are often hailed for precision, pigment intensity, and incredible layering capabilities. Their binder, typically an oleoresinous compound, deeply saturates paper fibers, allowing for extensive layering without surface build-up. Derwent, on the other hand, offers a fascinating array of lines – from the creamy wax-based Coloursoft (using binders like paraffin wax or microcrystalline wax) to the versatile Inktense – each with its own character and a reputation for innovation. It's not a question of 'which is objectively better,' but rather 'which is better for your style and needs.'

I vividly remember trying to force a wax-based pencil to behave like an oil one early in my career, and the frustration was real. Understanding these core differences – especially the role of the binder, the often-unsung hero that holds the pigment particles together – is your first step. The binder dictates everything: how smoothly a pencil glides, how many layers it accepts, how resistant it is to light, and even how it reacts to specific techniques like burnishing (applying heavy pressure to create a smooth, shiny, blended surface) or scumbling (applying light, circular strokes to create a textured, broken color effect). The chemical composition of the binder affects its hardness, how it interacts with paper fibers, and its receptiveness to solvents. Oil binders tend to penetrate paper fibers more deeply, creating a strong bond and allowing for extensive layering without a waxy build-up. Wax binders, while often softer for immediate color payoff, can sit more on the surface, leading to wax bloom if not managed. It's the silent architect of your colored pencil experience, truly unlocking their full potential and determining how well they adhere to different paper types for colored pencils.

credit, licence

credit, licence

Derwent: The British Innovator's Spectrum and Creative Freedom

Derwent, hailing from the UK's picturesque Lake District – a place steeped in artistic inspiration and home to the first pencil factory in the 1800s, building on a rich heritage of graphite mining – boasts a long, storied history. Initially focused on graphite, they truly carved out their niche in colored pencils by offering a wonderfully diverse range. It's almost as if they said, "Why settle for one type when you can have many?" This brand excels in offering a variety of core formulations to cater to diverse artistic approaches, positioning them as the brand for experimentation and pushing creative boundaries. They're about giving you options, encouraging you to break the rules (or at least, bend them wonderfully).

credit, licence

Derwent Coloursoft: The Creamy Dream for Expressive Art

My first encounter with Derwent was with their Coloursoft line. Oh, the creamy indulgence! These are famously soft, wax-based pencils that lay down color with such ease, it almost feels like painting. They blend beautifully and layer like a dream – perfect for broad strokes, quick, expressive sketches, and capturing soft, velvety textures in animal portraits. If you're into making bold, immediate statements, Coloursoft might just be your jam. I once used a deep Coloursoft blue to block in the sky of an expressive landscape, and the speed and vibrancy were just what I needed to capture that fleeting moment.

Derwent Inktense: The Ink Transformation for Mixed Media

Then there's Inktense. These are truly unique. They're like regular colored pencils until you add water, transforming into vibrant, translucent ink. It's pure magic, especially if you're experimenting with mixed media. I remember using Inktense to add a pop of intense, watercolor-like vibrancy to an otherwise abstract art piece, and the effect was stunning. It's a different beast entirely, but a fascinating one, capable of achieving bold washes or precise ink lines, and ideal for artists exploring mixed media. Ever wished your colored pencils could magically transform into ink? Inktense is your answer. If you want to literally activate the psychology of color on your page, Inktense is your friend.

credit, licence

Derwent Procolour, Artists, and Lightfast: Versatility and Archival Quality

Derwent's spirit of innovation doesn't stop there. Their Artists line offers a harder, more traditional wax-based pencil, providing good control for detailed work and sharper lines – a firmer alternative to Coloursoft. Then there's Procolour, which I consider a fantastic middle ground – it offers the vibrancy of Coloursoft but with a firmer point that's excellent for detail and less prone to breakage. It's quickly become a go-to for pieces needing both bold strokes and nuanced lines; I've used Procolour on a landscape commission where I needed to capture both the soft haze of distance and the sharp detail of foreground trees – it handled both tasks with surprising grace. And for those seeking professional archival quality, they offer the Lightfast line – their own professional-grade, oil-based pencils designed specifically for superior lightfastness, directly challenging Faber-Castell in that arena. Beyond these, you'll find Graphitint (water-soluble graphite with a hint of color, perfect for moody sketches), Pastel Pencils (for soft, chalky effects, similar to a pastel stick in wood), and their Drawing Pencils which offer rich, muted colors and an extra-wide strip, ideal for earthy tones and broad landscapes. This breadth of product truly showcases Derwent's commitment to exploring different possibilities within the colored pencil medium, catering to nearly every artistic whim, whether you're sketching, illustrating, or exploring new mixed media techniques.

Key Derwent Characteristics:

• Core Type & Binder: Primarily wax-based (Coloursoft, Artists, Procolour), but also unique water-soluble ink (Inktense, using a gum binder) and oil-based (Lightfast, using an oleoresinous binder). This diversity in binders is a core strength, offering different tactile experiences and working properties.
• Feel & Laydown: Ranges from the unrivaled creaminess of Coloursoft (smooth, rich laydown) to the firmer, more controlled glide of Artists and Procolour. Lightfast offers a firm, smooth oil feel, comparable to traditional oil-based pencils.
• Precision & Detail: While Coloursoft can be too soft for intricate work, Artists and Procolour provide good control. The Lightfast line excels in holding a fine point for detail, directly competing with oil-based competitors.
• Blending & Layering: Excellent blending for smooth transitions with wax-based lines, though excessive layering can lead to wax bloom. Inktense blends with water for vibrant washes and unique mixed media effects. Lightfast layers beautifully, mirroring high-performance oil pencil characteristics.
• Pigmentation & Density: Generally very good, with Coloursoft and Lightfast being particularly rich and intense. The pigment load is robust across their artist-grade lines, delivering vivid color.
• Lightfastness: Varies by line and color, but has significantly improved. The dedicated Lightfast line boasts professional archival quality, rated on the international Blue Wool Scale (a standard where ratings like 6-8 indicate excellent resistance to fading for 100+ years), directly competing with top-tier brands for permanence.
• Durability: Softer wax cores can be more prone to breakage if dropped or sharpened aggressively, but generally sturdy. Inktense and firmer wax lines are quite resilient. Lightfast pencils are very durable, typical of oil-based cores, often encased in high-quality cedar wood for strength.
• Erasability & Correction: Wax-based pencils can be challenging to erase completely, often leaving a ghosting effect. Kneaded erasers can lift some pigment, and sticky tack can be effective for lighter layers. Inktense, once water-activated, is largely permanent.
• Unique Effects: Inktense's transformation into vibrant, translucent ink when water is added is a unique selling point for mixed media artists, offering watercolor-like effects. Graphitint's subtle color within graphite offers unique moody tones.
• Paper Interaction: Wax-based lines love papers with a slight tooth (texture) for blending and scumbling. Inktense performs best on watercolor paper (both hot-press and cold-press) without buckling. Lightfast works well on various surfaces, from smooth Bristol to textured papers, for detailed layering and precise lines.
• Scent: Generally odorless, consistent with most wax-based pencils.

Faber-Castell: The German Master of Precision and Archival Quality

Now, let's turn our gaze to the venerable German house of Faber-Castell. These folks have been making art supplies for centuries – their history is practically entwined with the history of modern drawing, dating back to 1761. Their innovations, such as standardizing pencil hardness grades (the familiar 'H' and 'B' system), had a global impact on pencil manufacturing. This deep heritage in creating reliable, high-quality drawing instruments, including their famous Castell 9000 graphite pencils (a personal favorite for precise sketching pencils for artists), underpins their authority in the art world. When I think of Faber-Castell colored pencils, one line immediately springs to mind: Polychromos – truly their crown jewel and benchmark for artist-grade colored pencils. The name itself, "Polychromos," means "many colors" – a fitting testament to their vibrant range.

credit, licence

Faber-Castell Polychromos: The Gold Standard for Detail and Durability

Polychromos are the gold standard for many professional artists, and for good reason. They are oil-based, which gives them a distinctly different feel from most wax-based pencils. They're harder, hold a super fine point, and are fantastic for intricate detail. Layering with Polychromos is an absolute dream; you can build up so many layers without any sign of wax bloom (that hazy film common to wax pencils), achieving incredible depth and subtle transitions. This oil binder (an oleoresinous compound, often a mix of vegetable oil and resin) also contributes to a consistency and predictability in color application that is crucial for professional illustrators, designers, and anyone requiring exact color matching across multiple artworks. The oil actively saturates the paper fibers without leaving a waxy residue on the surface, which is why extensive layering is possible without issue. If you're striving for precision in your abstract art, detailed botanical illustrations, or mastering perspective in architectural drawings, these are your workhorses. I remember a particularly challenging commission where rendering the subtle reflections in glass demanded the precision and layering power only Polychromos could provide. It truly saved the day. For a more detailed look, check out this in-depth review of Faber-Castell Polychromos colored pencils.

Beyond Polychromos: Other Faber-Castell Offerings

While Polychromos are their artist-grade crown jewel, it's worth noting Faber-Castell also offers Classic Colour Pencils for aspiring artists and students, and their highly regarded PITT Artist Pens, which, while ink-based, often find a place alongside colored pencils in mixed media. They also offer the PITT Pastel Pencils, which are essentially a pastel stick encased in wood. They're brilliant for soft, chalky effects and blending, but they're a whole different animal than their Polychromos cousins. For this direct comparison of artist-grade colored pencils, though, Polychromos remain the singular benchmark for pure colored pencil performance from Faber-Castell.

credit, licence

Key Faber-Castell Characteristics:

• Core Type & Binder: Exclusively oil-based (Polychromos), using an oleoresinous binder, providing a consistent, firm, and wax-bloom-free application. This unique oil binder saturates paper fibers for deep color and excellent adhesion.
• Feel & Laydown: Medium-hard, smooth, with a satisfying resistance as the pigment sinks into the paper. They feel like an extension of your thought, almost a surgical instrument for your art, offering controlled, predictable results. Pressure sensitivity allows for a wide range of values, from delicate glazes to rich saturation.
• Precision & Detail: Unrivaled. Polychromos hold a super fine point for extended periods, making them ideal for intricate work, fine lines, and hyperrealism. They feel solid and reliable, perfect for microscopic detail.
• Blending & Layering: Exceptional ability to build countless layers without resistance or wax bloom, allowing for deep, luminous colors and incredibly smooth transitions. They also respond beautifully to solvent blending (with odorless mineral spirits like Zest-It or Gamsol), creating seamless, paint-like effects and allowing for advanced glazing (applying transparent layers to build color and depth).
• Pigmentation & Density: Extremely high pigment load across the entire range, resulting in vibrant, rich, and consistently true colors. They retain their vibrancy exceptionally well due to the high pigment-to-binder ratio.
• Lightfastness: Generally excellent to superb across the Polychromos range. Rated using the international Blue Wool Scale (with most colors scoring 7 or 8, indicating maximum permanence, resistant to fading for 100+ years) and ASTM D6901 standards, guaranteeing archival quality artwork that will endure for generations.
• Durability: Very durable, break-resistant cores due to their oil binder composition and SV bonding (a special secure-bonding technique that reinforces the lead within the cedar wood casing). This means less crumbling during sharpening or use, and greater longevity for the pencil itself, a significant benefit for artists. Their high-quality California cedar wood casing also contributes to clean sharpening.
• Erasability & Correction: While not perfectly erasable, Polychromos offer better lifting than wax-based pencils, especially with vinyl or sticky erasers, allowing for subtle corrections and highlights. Solvents can also be used for lifting pigment for highlights or texture.
• Unique Effects: Excels in achieving subtle effects like glazing, solvent lifting (using solvent to lift pigment for highlights or texture), and delicate color shifts through extensive layering, mimicking oil painting techniques. The oil binder allows for a broader range of pressure application without immediately saturating the paper.
• Paper Interaction: Polychromos excel on a wide variety of papers. Their fine point and layering capabilities are particularly suited for papers with a fine tooth or smooth surfaces like Bristol board (e.g., Strathmore Bristol Smooth), allowing for both crisp details and rich, burnished effects. They also perform beautifully on various watercolor papers (both hot-press and cold-press) without disturbing the surface, making them excellent for precise work on absorbent surfaces.
• Scent: Can have a very faint, slightly earthy or woody scent, consistent with oil-based products and cedar casing. Rarely an issue for most artists.

Head-to-Head: The Ultimate Showdown on the Canvas

Alright, let's put these artist-grade colored pencils on the canvas, so to speak. This is where personal preference truly comes into play, but I'll give you my unfiltered thoughts on the key battlegrounds. Remember, both brands offer exceptional professional colored pencils – it's about finding your perfect match. This table offers a concise overview, but the sections that follow delve deeper into the nuances that truly matter.

Feature	Derwent (e.g., Coloursoft/Artists/Lightfast)	Faber-Castell (Polychromos)	Best For
Core Type	Primarily wax-based (Coloursoft, Artists, Procolour); also water-soluble ink (Inktense) & oil (Lightfast)	Oil-based	Broad artistic spectrum & innovation (Derwent) vs. precision & permanence (Faber-Castell)
Core Binder	Wax (most lines), water-soluble gum (Inktense), oleoresinous oil (Lightfast)	Oleoresinous Oil	Mixed media/expressive washes (Derwent) vs. fine art/archival detail (Faber-Castell)
Hardness/Feel	Soft to medium-soft, creamy laydown (Coloursoft); firmer for Artists, Procolour & Lightfast	Medium-hard, smooth yet firm, satisfying resistance	Quick, expressive coverage (Derwent) vs. intricate detail/controlled layering (Faber-Castell)
Pigmentation	Rich, vibrant (especially Coloursoft, Lightfast); good pigment load across lines	Extremely high, vivid, consistent; exceptional vibrancy retention & luminosity	Expressive, immediate color (Derwent) vs. lasting, consistent depth of color (Faber-Castell)
Blending	Excellent for smooth transitions, rich color mixes (Coloursoft); Inktense blends with water	Very good, subtle, controlled blends; excels with solvents for seamless transitions	Soft gradients, textural blends (Derwent wax) vs. seamless, paint-like blends (Faber-Castell oil)
Layering	Good, but wax bloom possible with many layers (wax-based); Lightfast layers exceptionally well	Exceptional, can build many layers without wax bloom, resistance, or lifting	Initial broad layers, expressive build-up (Derwent) vs. infinite depth & texture (Faber-Castell)
Detail Work	Good with Artists, Procolour & Lightfast lines; Coloursoft can be too soft for very fine details	Excellent, holds a super fine point for intricate precision and sustained fine lines	Controlled lines/textures (Derwent firm) vs. microscopic detail/hyperrealism (Faber-Castell)
Lightfastness	Varies by line/color; generally good, improving (Lightfast is top-tier, rated on Blue Wool Scale, typically 6-8)	Generally excellent to superb (rated using Blue Wool Scale and ASTM standards, typically 7-8)	Non-archival expressive (Derwent wax) vs. gallery/museum archival (Faber-Castell)
Durability	Softer wax cores can be more brittle if dropped; Inktense and oil-based Lightfast are sturdy	Very durable, break-resistant cores due to oil binder composition and SV bonding	Robust everyday use (Faber-Castell) vs. careful handling (Derwent softer wax)
Erasability	Moderate (wax-based, some ghosting); low to none (water-activated Inktense)	Good (can lift well with appropriate erasers/solvents for corrections)	Corrections/Highlights (Faber-Castell) vs. permanent media (Derwent Inktense)
Solvent Blending	Limited (wax-based); transforms dramatically with water (Inktense)	Excellent, pigment dissolves beautifully for paint-like effects and seamless gradients	Watercolor effects (Derwent Inktense) vs. oil painting/glazing effects (Faber-Castell)
Scent	Generally odorless	Very faint, earthy/woody scent (from oil binder/cedar wood)	No preference (Derwent) vs. subtle natural scent (Faber-Castell)
Price Point	High-end, similar to Polychromos for professional lines, reflecting quality pigments and innovative binders	High-end, professional-grade, reflecting centuries of expertise and premium materials	Professional investment for serious artists

credit, licence

Core Composition: Wax vs. Oil (and Water-Soluble Ink): The Heart of the Matter

This is perhaps the biggest differentiator, and it dictates so much of the pencil's behavior. Derwent's wax-based pencils, like Coloursoft, feel incredibly buttery. They glide on the paper, depositing a lot of pigment quickly, laying down like butter on toast, leaving a rich, satiny sheen. This is fantastic for speed and bold coverage. The wax binders (often paraffin or microcrystalline wax) sit more on the paper's surface. However, with excessive layering, especially in humid conditions, you might start seeing wax bloom – a hazy, whitish film caused by the wax binders rising to the surface. It’s not the end of the world (you can often fix it with a soft cloth or specialized fixatives), but it's something to be aware of primarily with wax-based pencils. Derwent's Inktense, with its unique water-soluble ink binder (a gum arabic based compound), offers another dimension entirely, allowing for dynamic transitions from dry pencil to vibrant liquid ink, almost like a controlled watercolor. It's akin to having a chameleon in your art box.

Faber-Castell Polychromos, being oil-based, feel firmer. They don't lay down as much pigment in one go, encouraging a slow, controlled build-up of layers. The beauty here is that you can layer endlessly without worrying about wax bloom. The oil binder in Polychromos (an oleoresinous compound) actively saturates the paper fibers without leaving a waxy residue on the surface, which is why you can layer so extensively without fear of wax bloom. This allows for incredibly smooth gradations and deep, luminous colors that truly sink into the paper. It's like a slow, satisfying dance with your medium, offering a predictable resistance, like a well-tuned instrument. This oil binder also makes them incredibly receptive to solvent blending; the pigment truly dissolves and flows almost like paint, rather than just being pushed around, allowing for seamless, paint-like washes. It's a different experience than watercolor washes from Inktense, offering more of an oil painting effect and allowing you to achieve complex glazing effects similar to those in oil paints for beginners.

credit, licence

Color Range & Pigmentation: The Science of Lasting Color

Both brands offer extensive color ranges, and their pigments are generally top-notch. Faber-Castell Polychromos are renowned for their incredible lightfastness, which is crucial for professional artists who need their work to last for generations. Their pigment load is consistently high, resulting in vibrant, rich colors that stay true. They are meticulously tested and often rated using the international Blue Wool Scale (a standard for measuring lightfastness, where ratings range from 1 to 8, with 8 indicating maximum resistance to fading; a score of 7-8 typically means your artwork will show no noticeable fading for 100+ years under museum conditions) and ASTM D6901 standards, ensuring exceptional vibrancy retention over time. When I think about creating pieces destined for the den bosch museum or any long-term display, lightfastness is a non-negotiable – a testament to the archival quality of your work. It's a promise to future generations that your colors will remain as vivid as the day you laid them down.

Derwent has made huge strides in lightfastness, especially with lines like their Lightfast pencils (their dedicated oil-based offering). While Polychromos have historically been the benchmark, Derwent's Lightfast line offers comparable archival quality, with most colors scoring 6-8 on the Blue Wool Scale, making them a strong contender for permanence and ensuring your art will be as vibrant years from now as it is today.

credit, licence

Blending & Layering: Mastering Transitions and Depth with Precision

This is where my personal preference truly leans into the nuances. For sheer, effortless blending on the first few layers, Derwent Coloursoft often wins my heart. They merge so smoothly, creating beautiful transitions and soft gradients. But for layering to achieve deep, luminous effects, intricate textures, or subtle color shifts, Polychromos are unparalleled. I can build up twenty layers with Polychromos and still feel like I have control, whereas wax-based pencils often start to resist new layers after just a few, creating that dreaded waxy build-up. The oil-based nature of Polychromos also makes them incredibly receptive to solvent blending, allowing the pigments to spread and meld almost like paint, erasing pencil strokes and creating seamless color fields. It's a technique that opens up possibilities for delicate glazing, creating luminous depth, and even solvent lifting (using solvent to lift pigment for highlights or texture) – truly pushing the boundaries of what colored pencils can do. It's a key reason why artists seeking to achieve complex textures and profound depth in their work often reach for them, embodying the principles of texture in abstract art. The consistent pressure sensitivity of Polychromos allows for precise control from light washes to heavy saturation, making them ideal for building nuanced effects.

credit, licence

Price & Accessibility: An Investment in Your Artistry

Both brands sit at the higher end of the colored pencil spectrum. These are professional-grade colored pencils, and their price reflects that. You're paying for quality pigments, durable cores, and consistent performance backed by centuries of expertise (in Faber-Castell's case) or relentless innovation (for Derwent). While you might find student-grade options from both (like Faber-Castell's Classic Colour Pencils or Derwent Academy), this comparison focuses purely on their artist-grade lines. Expect individual open stock pencils to range from $2.50 to $5.00 USD, while sets of 24 or 36 can easily be $50-100+, depending on the line. It's an investment, but one that truly pays off in the quality and longevity of your work. My studio (and probably my bank account's dismay) resembles a well-stocked art supply store, a testament to my ongoing quest for the 'perfect' tool – it's the artist's dilemma, isn't it? Think of it like buying a quality paintbrush versus a flimsy one; the experience and outcome are worlds apart. A great tip for beginners or those on a budget is to buy individual pencils (open stock) in key colors. This is a cost-effective way to get a feel for their unique properties, especially on your preferred paper, before committing to a full set. It lets you test different binders, hardnesses, and colors, helping you identify your personal preferences without a massive upfront investment. It's a strategy I wish I'd embraced earlier in my artistic journey. Also, consider the packaging: tins are great for studio storage but can be cumbersome for travel; cardboard boxes are lighter but offer less protection. Faber-Castell's sturdy tin sets are often preferred for studio use, while Derwent's lighter cardboard or smaller tins are more portable. Think about how you'll use and transport your pencils, as packaging durability and weight are critical for artists who travel or work plein air.

The Role of Paper: Your Unsung Hero and Co-conspirator

It's easy to focus solely on the pencils, but paper choice is an absolute game-changer, significantly impacting how both Derwent and Faber-Castell pencils perform. Paper with a good tooth (the texture or roughness of the surface) allows for more layers and better pigment adhesion, especially with the layering capabilities of Polychromos. For instance, highly toothy papers like Stonehenge or Canson Mi-Teintes (the textured side) can 'grab' more pigment, allowing wax-based pencils like Coloursoft to build up vibrant layers more effectively. They also perform beautifully for techniques like scumbling, creating a vibrant, broken-color texture. If you're working with the elements of art, paper becomes a crucial partner.

Conversely, smoother surfaces like Bristol board (e.g., Strathmore Bristol Smooth) or hot-press watercolor papers (e.g., Arches Hot-Press) are fantastic for the incredibly fine details and smooth gradations that Polychromos excel at, as there's less texture to interfere with delicate lines. These papers are also ideal for burnishing, where you apply heavy pressure to create a smooth, polished, almost paint-like finish. For Inktense, a good watercolor paper (e.g., Arches Cold-Press, Fabriano Artistico) is non-negotiable, allowing the water to activate the ink without buckling or excessive bleeding. It also ensures the rich washes of Inktense are absorbed beautifully. Experimenting with different paper types for colored pencils, from hot-press to cold-press, is just as crucial as choosing your pencils. My studio already reflects this philosophy of accumulating various tools and surfaces in the endless pursuit of the 'perfect' combination. The paper is truly your co-conspirator in art, ready to elevate or hinder your chosen medium.

credit, licence

When to Choose Derwent: For the Explorer and Expressive Artist

If your artistic style leans towards fluidity, vibrant immediate color, and experimental mixed-media techniques, Derwent's diverse range might just be your creative soulmate. You know, there are days when I just want to lay down swathes of vibrant color without much fuss. If that sounds like you, or if these points resonate, Derwent might be your champion:

credit, licence

• Creamy, Soft Application: Coloursoft is pure joy for broad strokes, smooth coverage, and achieving rich, velvety textures quickly. It's like butter on paper, perfect for rapid color blocking and expressive layering. Ideal for impressionistic landscapes or soft animal portraits, delivering immediate impact.
• Mixed Media & Innovative Effects: Inktense is a game-changer if you want to combine the precision of pencil with the vibrancy of ink or watercolor. It opens up so many possibilities for dynamic effects and experimental approaches, transforming your art into something truly unique, offering a taste of definitive guide to paint types for artists with the control of a pencil.
• Innovation and Variety: Derwent consistently pushes boundaries with different formulations, offering diverse core types (wax, oil, water-soluble ink) for every artistic whim, encouraging exploration and unique stylistic development. Their lines like Graphitint or Drawing pencils expand creative horizons even further.
• Speed, Bold Color Payoff, & Expressive Application: For projects where you need to cover large areas quickly and make a strong, immediate visual impact, their softer pencils deliver instant gratification and expressive power, responding well to varied pressure for diverse effects.
• Superior Lightfastness in an Oil-Based Pencil from a British Brand: Their Lightfast line is a direct answer to Polychromos, offering comparable archival quality and detail, but with a distinct Derwent feel, for when you need permanence with a touch of British innovation.

When to Choose Faber-Castell Polychromos: For the Precisionist and Archival Artisan

For artists who prize meticulous detail, controlled application, and artwork destined to endure the test of time, Faber-Castell Polychromos are often the unparalleled choice. Then there are the days I want to get lost in the details, meticulously building up texture and depth. For those moments, and for artists who value these qualities, Faber-Castell Polychromos are often the answer:

credit, licence

• Precision & Intricate Detail: Their hard, sharp point is perfect for realism, architectural drawings, tiny elements, or creating crisp lines without crumbling. They feel like a surgical instrument for your art, ideal for hyperrealistic portraits or intricate botanical studies. Their consistent performance under varying pressure allows for controlled fine lines and subtle build-up.
• Extensive Layering: The oil-based core prevents wax bloom and allows for countless layers, creating luminous depth, smooth gradations, and rich saturation that truly sinks into the paper, making them ideal for complex textures and subtle color shifts. This allows for unparalleled depth and painterly effects.
• Archival Quality is Paramount: Their exceptional lightfastness, backed by rigorous testing, means your artwork will endure for generations, a non-negotiable for professional work destined for galleries or important collections. This ensures your legacy.
• Firmer Feel & Consistent, Predictable Performance: They feel solid and reliable, allowing for maximum control and a satisfying resistance under your hand, instilling confidence with every stroke. This predictability is invaluable for professional commissions, much like relying on essential oil painting supplies for consistent results.
• Excellent Solvent Blending Capabilities: Polychromos respond beautifully to mineral spirits and other blending mediums, creating paint-like effects, seamless transitions, and enabling advanced rendering techniques like glazing and solvent lifting. This truly expands the artistic possibilities of the medium.

My Personal Take: It's Not Either/Or (Mostly, But Also Sometimes Both!)

So, after all that, which do I prefer? It’s almost impossible to pick just one, and frankly, I don't think you have to. My studio reflects this philosophy. I find myself reaching for different tools depending on the specific project, the paper I'm using, and even my mood that day. It's part of the artist's journey, this accumulation and experimentation, this artistic evolution, a constant balancing act that ensures the ultimate artistic breakthrough rather than a Faustian bargain.

For bold, expressive pieces, or when I'm working quickly, a Derwent Coloursoft or even an Inktense might be my first grab. The immediate impact of their color is undeniable – I once started an abstract piece with a few quick Inktense washes, and the instant vibrancy truly set the tone. But when I'm diving into a portrait, a meticulous still life, or any work requiring sustained, delicate layering and absolute control, my Polychromos are almost always there, steadfast and reliable. It’s like having different brushes for different painting styles. You wouldn't use a tiny detail brush for a broad wash, would you? (Unless you're being particularly avant-garde, which, hey, I'm all for.)

The best scenario, if your budget allows, is to have a selection from both. Start with smaller sets, or even better, you can buy individual pencils (open stock) in key colors to test the waters without committing to a full set. This approach also allows beginners to gradually build their collection of artist-grade colored pencils without overwhelming investment. Remember, the journey of finding your perfect tools is just as exciting as the art you create. Dive into our artistic timeline to see how my own approach to tools and mediums has evolved over the years, or visit the den bosch museum page for inspiration on how art endures.

credit, licence

Troubleshooting & Tips for Best Results: Mastering Your Medium

Beyond choosing the right pencil, a few tricks can enhance your experience with both brands and help you maximize their potential, truly mastering your chosen medium:

credit, licence

credit, licence

Sharpening Techniques

For wax-based pencils, use a very sharp blade or a high-quality hand-held sharpener (like a helical sharpener) to minimize breakage, especially with softer cores. An electric sharpener can offer consistent, precise points, but always choose one with quality blades. Consider keeping a separate sharpener for each type to prevent wax residue transfer. If a lead breaks deep inside, try warming the pencil slightly (e.g., in indirect sunlight for a few minutes) to soften the binder before sharpening again. Oil-based pencils are more resilient due to their SV bonding and cedar wood casing but still benefit from sharp blades for a fine point and can withstand a bit more pressure during sharpening.

Preventing Wax Bloom

Beyond buffing with a soft cloth, consider applying a light layer of workable fixative specifically designed for colored pencils to seal the layers, especially on heavily worked wax-based pieces. Building layers with lighter pressure initially can also help. For ultimate protection and a uniform finish, a final art varnish can also be applied. Storing your artwork in a stable, less humid environment can significantly reduce the likelihood of wax bloom. To combat wax bloom, some artists even use a hairdryer on a low setting over their finished piece to re-melt the wax slightly, then buff.

credit, licence

Layering Strategies

Always work from lighter colors to darker colors to maintain clarity and avoid muddying, especially with wax-based pencils. For oil pencils, you have more freedom, but the principle still applies. Build up layers gradually, applying light to medium pressure for smooth transitions and rich saturation. Think of it as painting with tiny strokes, building depth slowly and thoughtfully, much like how to apply gesso to canvas for a beginners guide.

Blending Solvents & Erasability

For Polychromos, odorless mineral spirits (OMS), Zest-It, or turpentine alternatives can create beautiful, paint-like washes and seamless transitions. Apply sparingly with a cotton swab or brush. Always test on a scrap piece of your chosen paper first! This technique allows for impressive color fields and can completely erase pencil texture if desired, or be used for solvent lifting to create highlights. This can also help reduce the slight "drag" or resistance you might feel on certain papers when heavily layering. For corrections, vinyl erasers or sticky tack can be surprisingly effective for Polychromos, while wax-based pencils are more challenging to fully erase, often leaving a ghost. Inktense, once water-activated, is essentially permanent.

Storage & Care

Store colored pencils horizontally in trays or cases to prevent core breakage. Keep them away from extreme temperatures and humidity, which can affect the wax binder in particular (leading to crumbling or melting). Always recap water-soluble pencils like Inktense if working in a humid environment to prevent premature activation. Environmental factors truly impact the longevity of your tools and art. Investing in quality packaging, or even a sturdy travel case, helps protect your investment, especially for plein air painting.

Sustainability

Both brands have made efforts towards more sustainable practices. Faber-Castell uses FSC-certified wood (often California cedar) for many pencils and has a carbon-neutral production. Derwent has focused on reducing waste, improving packaging, and using sustainably sourced materials. While not the primary decision factor for most artists, it's a worthwhile consideration for those looking to minimize their environmental footprint.

Testing & Experimentation

If you're unsure which brand or line is for you, start by purchasing individual pencils (open stock) in key colors. This is a cost-effective way to get a feel for their unique properties on your preferred paper before committing to a full set. Don't be afraid to mix and match brands within the same artwork to leverage their best characteristics – for example, Faber-Castell vs. Prismacolor colored pencils is another common artist's dilemma. Embrace the exploration!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: Can I mix Derwent and Faber-Castell colored pencils in one artwork?

A: Absolutely! This is where the magic truly happens. Their different properties can actually complement each other beautifully. For example, you could lay down a smooth, vibrant base with Derwent Coloursoft for general hues, then add fine details, crisp lines, and achieve rich, layered shadows with Faber-Castell Polychromos on top. Experiment to find combinations that work for you and create unique textures and depths. The key is understanding each pencil's strengths and how they interact with each other and the paper. There's no rule against artistic synergy!

credit, licence

Q: Are Derwent Inktense pencils good for beginners?

A: Derwent Inktense pencils are incredibly fun and versatile, making them great for beginners who want to explore different effects. They behave like regular colored pencils but transform into vibrant, transparent ink when water is added. This duality offers a lot of creative freedom, though mastering the water activation and brush control might take a little practice. Start with small swatches to get a feel for their unique properties, and don't be afraid to make a mess – it's part of the discovery! They can be a fantastic gateway into mixed media for new artists, offering a taste of paint types for artists with the control of a pencil.

credit, licence

Q: What is "wax bloom" and how can I avoid it with wax-based pencils?

A: Wax bloom is a hazy, whitish film that can appear on artworks made with wax-based colored pencils, especially when many layers are applied or in humid conditions. It's caused by wax binders rising to the surface. To avoid it, use lighter pressure, build up layers gradually, and apply a specialized colored pencil fixative when finished. You can often gently buff it away with a soft cloth before applying fixative. Ensuring your artwork is stored in a stable, less humid environment can also help, as can a final art varnish, similar to how one might varnish an oil painting.

Q: Are Faber-Castell Polychromos lightfast?

A: Yes, Faber-Castell Polychromos are renowned for their excellent to superb lightfastness. Most colors are rated with one or two stars (indicating very good to maximum lightfastness) on the Blue Wool Scale and meet ASTM D6901 standards, meaning they are highly resistant to fading over time when exposed to light. This makes them a top choice for professional artists who need their artwork to be archival and endure for generations. While Polychromos are a benchmark, remember that Derwent's oil-based Lightfast line is also designed for superior lightfastness, offering a strong alternative.

credit, licence

Q: Which brand is better for detailed work?

A: For extremely detailed work, Faber-Castell Polychromos generally have an edge. Their oil-based cores are harder, hold a much finer point for longer, and allow for precise application without excessive crumbling or frequent sharpening, which is ideal for intricate precision, realism, or technical illustrations. While Derwent's firmer lines like Artists or Lightfast are good for detail, Polychromos often win for the most microscopic and sustained intricate precision. If your work involves tiny lines and complex textures, Polychromos truly shine.

credit, licence

Q: How do Derwent and Faber-Castell compare to other popular brands like Prismacolor?

A: While this article focuses on the in-depth comparison of Derwent and Faber-Castell, it's worth noting that Prismacolor Premier pencils are another highly popular artist-grade, wax-based option known for their extreme softness and vibrant laydown. They are often compared to Derwent Coloursoft for their creamy feel. However, Prismacolor pencils can be more prone to breakage and wax bloom than Derwent, and typically have lower lightfastness ratings than Polychromos. Each brand has its unique strengths, and your choice often comes down to specific artistic needs and preferences. Exploring an in-depth review of Prismacolor Premier colored pencils can provide more context.

credit, licence

Q: What's the difference between artist-grade and student-grade colored pencils?

A: Artist-grade colored pencils, like the professional lines of Derwent and Faber-Castell discussed here, contain a higher concentration of pure pigment, superior lightfastness, and more durable binders, resulting in richer colors, better blending, and artwork longevity. Student-grade pencils have less pigment, more filler, and lower lightfastness, making them more affordable but less suitable for professional or archival work. They're excellent for practice and experimentation, but for serious artwork, investing in artist-grade is a game-changer – it genuinely elevates your creative output and the lifespan of your pieces. It’s akin to using quality oil paints for beginners versus craft-store alternatives. This investment is key to mastering your medium.

Q: Do oil-based pencils have a noticeable smell compared to wax-based ones?

A: Yes, sometimes. Faber-Castell Polychromos, being oil-based, can have a very faint, slightly earthy or woody scent, often attributed to the oil binder itself or the cedar wood casing. It's usually very subtle and not unpleasant. Wax-based pencils, in contrast, are generally odorless. The scent of Polychromos is rarely an issue for most artists, but it's a detail some notice as part of their unique tactile and sensory experience. This is one of those subtle sensory elements that makes each medium unique.

Q: How important is pencil set packaging for artists who travel or work plein air?

A: Packaging is surprisingly important for portability! Heavy wooden boxes or large tins are fantastic for studio organization and protection but cumbersome for travel. Lighter tins or compact cases designed for a smaller selection of pencils are ideal for plein air work or when you need to take your art on the go. Consider if the pencils are securely held to prevent breakage during transport, especially softer wax cores. For the intrepid artist, a durable, well-organized case can make all the difference in protecting your investment and ensuring your tools are ready when inspiration strikes on the go. Many brands offer specialized travel cases now, so it’s worth seeking them out.

Final Musings: Your Artistic Voice, Your Tools, Your Journey

At the end of the day, the choice between Derwent and Faber-Castell isn't a declaration of war; it's an exploration of preference. Both brands offer exceptional quality and have earned their stellar reputations as creators of professional colored pencils. Your art journey is personal, and the tools you choose should feel like a natural extension of your hand and your artistic voice. It’s all about finding what empowers your creativity, what allows you to express your vision most authentically. And let's be honest, sometimes the joy is in the exploration itself, the tactile pleasure of a new pencil on fresh paper, the thrilling discovery of a new technique. This ongoing quest for the 'perfect' tool is part of being an artist, constantly evolving alongside your craft, ensuring that your journey is always an artistic breakthrough, never a Faustian bargain. Remember, the pencils are simply instruments; your skill, vision, and heart are the true masters.

credit, licence

credit, licence

So, try them out, see how they feel on your chosen paper, and listen to what your intuition tells you. Happy creating – and remember, the best colored pencils are ultimately the ones that help you make your best art! Explore our curated collection of art supplies to find your next creative companion, and perhaps share your own experiences and discoveries in the comments below; I'd genuinely love to hear them. What's your go-to pencil for capturing vibrant color or meticulous detail, and why? Do you have a favorite solvent blending technique, or a particular paper pairing you swear by? What new technique has transformed your colored pencil work? I'm always eager to learn from fellow artists!